The Counterfeit Problem is Real
Sophisticated counterfeits, often from China, are flooding the market. Fake gold bars, silver eagles, and coins are increasingly difficult to detect visually. Some fakes even contain real precious metals with tungsten cores. Vigilance is essential.
The best defense against counterfeits is buying from reputable dealers. But whether you're buying from an individual, estate sale, or just want to verify your holdings, these tests can help you identify fakes.
The First Line of Defense: Buy Smart
Prevention is better than detection. Follow these rules to minimize counterfeit risk:
- Buy from established dealers: APMEX, JM Bullion, SD Bullion, etc. have rigorous authentication processes.
- Avoid too-good-to-be-true prices: If someone offers gold 10% below spot, it's probably fake.
- Be wary of eBay and Craigslist: Counterfeit hotspots. If you must, use eBay's buyer protection.
- Buy recognizable products: American Eagles, Maple Leafs, PAMP bars—not obscure brands.
- Request assay certificates: For large purchases, get documentation.
Basic Tests (No Equipment Needed)
1. Visual Inspection
Compare the coin or bar to images from the official mint. Look for:
- Blurry or poorly defined details
- Wrong color or luster
- Seams or mold lines
- Incorrect weight or dimensions (measure with calipers)
- Misspellings or incorrect text
- Missing security features (reeds, edge lettering, micro-engraving)
2. The Magnet Test
Gold and silver are not magnetic. If a strong magnet (neodymium) sticks to your metal, it's fake.
Limitation: This test only catches cheap fakes made with magnetic metals. Sophisticated fakes using tungsten, lead, or copper will pass this test.
3. The Ping Test (Silver)
Silver has a distinctive, high-pitched ring when struck. Tap a silver coin on your fingernail or another coin and listen for a clear, sustained ring. Fake silver makes a dull thud.
Apps like "Bullion Test" can analyze the sound frequency to verify silver purity.
4. The Ice Test (Silver)
Silver has the highest thermal conductivity of any metal. Place an ice cube on a silver coin—it should melt noticeably faster than on other surfaces. Real silver will feel cold to the touch and quickly reach body temperature when held.
5. Weight and Dimensions
Gold and silver have specific densities that are hard to fake:
- Gold: 19.3 g/cm³
- Silver: 10.5 g/cm³
- Tungsten: 19.25 g/cm³ (this is why it's used in fakes)
Use a precise scale (0.01g accuracy) and calipers to measure weight and dimensions. Compare to official specifications from the mint.
Advanced Tests (Equipment Required)
6. Sigma Metalytics Precious Metal Verifier
The gold standard for home testing. Uses electromagnetic waves to measure the conductivity of the metal beneath the surface. Can detect tungsten-filled bars and accurately identify gold, silver, and platinum.
Sigma Metalytics ($700-1,500)
- • Tests gold, silver, platinum, palladium
- • Detects tungsten cores
- • Works through plastic holders/capsules
- • Non-destructive
- • Worth it for serious collectors ($50K+ holdings)
7. XRF (X-Ray Fluorescence) Testing
Professional-grade testing that measures elemental composition. Used by dealers, pawn shops, and refiners. XRF guns cost $15,000-50,000 but can be rented or found at local testing services.
Limitation: XRF only tests the surface layer. A gold-plated tungsten bar will test as pure gold because XRF can't see beneath the plating.
8. Ultrasonic Thickness Testing
Uses sound waves to detect irregularities inside bars. Can find tungsten cores or voids. Often combined with XRF for comprehensive testing.
9. Specific Gravity Test
A classic physics test. Weigh the item in air, then weigh it suspended in water. The difference reveals the density, which should match gold (19.3 g/cm³) or silver (10.5 g/cm³).
Common Counterfeit Types
Tungsten-Core Gold Bars
Tungsten has nearly identical density to gold. Sophisticated fakes drill out real gold bars and insert tungsten cores, then re-seal. Only Sigma, ultrasonic, or drilling can detect these.
Gold-Plated Coins
Base metal coins with thin gold plating. Often fail weight/dimension tests. The plating may wear off at edges over time.
Fake Silver Eagles
Very common. Often made of copper-nickel or lead with silver plating. Weight, sound, and ice tests usually catch these.
"Copy" or "Replica" Coins
Some sellers list fakes as "copies" in small print. These are legal to sell if marked, but often end up being resold as genuine by scammers.
Testing Checklist
Quick Authentication Protocol
- 1. Visual inspection: Compare to official images, check details
- 2. Measure: Weight (scale) and dimensions (calipers)
- 3. Magnet test: Should NOT stick
- 4. Ping test (silver): Should ring clearly
- 5. Sigma test: If available, confirms metal content
- 6. When in doubt: Get professional verification
What to Do If You Suspect a Fake
- Don't accuse the seller immediately: Get professional verification first.
- Document everything: Photos, receipts, communications.
- If confirmed fake: Report to local law enforcement and the FTC.
- eBay/PayPal: File a claim immediately if bought online.
- Credit card: Dispute the charge with your card company.
The Simplest Solution
Buy from reputable dealers listed on FindBullion. All our listed dealers have authentication processes and guarantees. The small premium you pay for dealer purchases is insurance against counterfeits.
Buy from Trusted Dealers
Compare prices from verified, reputable dealers and avoid counterfeit risks.
View Dealers